Netflix Movie Fans

I give out very few 5 star ratings of movies. To me, a movie must be a masterpiece or really hit home on a personal level to get 5 stars. I feel that 4 stars is appropriate for even some of my favorite movies.

Others seem to give out 5 star ratings like candy. Even a movie like "Jaws:The Revenge" has some 5 star reviews - come on now...

What is your criteria for a 5 star rating and do you have any 5 star ratings of movies that were mostly hated by everyone else?

Tags: ratings, reviews

Views: 2254

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

the difference for me is that the fifth star goes to movies I love and WANT to watch again. it's not so much a reflection of quality as it is personal enjoyment.
Yep, the movie may be terrible by anyone elses standards, but not by mine, thus five stars cause I would watch that film again and again and again.
DITTO!!
Ditto. And if I don't care for so many rec's and want to be more honest, I'll give it a 4. Every so often I go through my 3,4,5 star ratings and decide whether I should change them and which way.
I do it the same way. I have about 5 movies out of 150 that make 5 stars.
A very few of my ratings are 5 star.... i'm kinda the same that way..... very picky ..4 stars is fine for a great movie.
102 5-star movies out of 3626 ratings. I agree with B-Independent on personal enjoyment over film quality. Films that I awarded 5 stars are films I could watch over and over, that blew me away or have left a lasting impression.
I have a few that on some personal level connect and I can watch maybe once a year that get 5 stars if only to recommend to others. Otherwise they need to be masterpieces.
So what is a "masterpiece" if you're differentiating it from films that you connect to on a personal level?
Any movie that I love, really really love will get a 5 star from me. Sometimes that means its a classic which is well acted, beautifully filmed, won tons of awards.... and other times its just a movie that made me laugh and that i actually want to see more then once. I gave a five star rating to the movie Blow Dry. It probably got more bad ratings then good, but I really enjoyed it. The rating system really is relative. For me its actually harder to rate something a 1 star then five stars. i have plenty of movies I love, but not many that I hated. So in the end most of my ratings are 3 stars since i didn't hate them, didn't love them. Even a 2 star means didn't like...
It is interesting how the two camps tend to look down their noses at one another. I don't care, in comparison, whether I give many or few 5-star ratings. If a film really moves me, I might buy it and would certainly watch again, I'll give it five stars. Four stars for really liked it, might watch again. Three stars for glad I saw it, wouldn't want to again. Two stars for it was pretty bad but had at least a few qualities I could enjoy. One star for 'hated it'. I think those are pretty close to the Netflix guidelines. My voting has made the Netflix recommendations work really well for me. That's all that matters in the end, isn't it?
Thanks, Chawk! I'd never heard of The Big White until you mentioned it. Now it's on my Q and I'm looking forward to seeing it!

RSS

Badge

Loading…

Latest Activity

Nerves replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"The Furies (1950)Anthony Mann grew up in a Theosophical Society commune in San Diego where he was exposed to productions of Greek tragedies and Shakespeare's plays presented in the commune's replica Ancient Greek amphitheater. This…"
6 hours ago
Profile Iconluap, OPTIMUS124 and Zenlaineyiks joined Netflix Movie Fans
21 hours ago
David replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
"I thought it was Larry Fine at first."
yesterday
David replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
" "
yesterday
eviltimes replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"Just watched the Chelsea Lately Finale.  Craziest show with the biggest stars to rival the Emmys!  A ton of fun.  ♫  So roll a joint and have a drink ♫"
yesterday
David replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"I watched the PBS Ken Burns doc on George Custer last night.  He's finishing up a new doc on FDR, should be good.  Here's a doc on Kate Bush, the Brit rock singer if interested:…"
yesterday
eviltimes replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
" "
yesterday
eviltimes replied to Evil Herbivore's discussion 'And the 2014 Emmy goes to...' in the group Television
"Agree with on every count.  Too bad the Sherlock guys were not there!  And what was it with the dresses?  1960's "Fashion Of The Future" silliness?  Didn't Jane Jetson wear those crazy things?"
yesterday
Netflowers replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
" "
yesterday
Nerves replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"Stranger on the Third Floor (1940)What starts out as a seemingly routine B movie crime story involving a reporter who becomes the star witness in a murder trial quickly turns into a cinematic masterpiece when we enter the mind of the reporter…"
yesterday
Pihk left a comment for ¿Mr. Bad?
"Sexploitationastic!"
Wednesday
eviltimes replied to Evil Herbivore's discussion 'Football 2014-2015: who is ready?!?' in the group Netflix Fantasy Football
"Soon, oh so very soon. Thanks for everything, Spin."
Tuesday

© 2014   Created by droidmaker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service