Netflix Movie Fans

I havent usually read this complaint in forums like this one, but i find this to be a very important problem in Netflix. 

Many films in Netflix are not being shown as they should. Some very wide films, that usually appear with black bars on top and above the image, are cutted to fill a standard television screen.

I dont understand the reason in this. Ive never heard of anyone not wanting to see a movie cause it had black bars. But I myself dont want to see films cropped like that.
Why is this?
Let me explain.

We know that films can tell stories. But the story in a film is not only told with the dialogue, but also with the image. You could see a film were two characters talk to each other, while another sits and waits. What if you couldnt see the one that waits? You could still hear the conversation, but you would lose the information on an entire character. Why was he waiting? Didnt he had anything to say? Was it because he didnt want to get involved? We would never know. We dont even know he was siting there in the first place. All this questions are gone if the film is cut and you lose a small part of the image.
This happens in Netflix with some films, and it should stop. No one wins with the situation as it is.

I made this website were I am going to post screenshots of both versions of the films to compare the results. I am doing it cause I want people to be concerned about it. To realize what a problem is. Please do not consider this as Spam.

http://whatnetflixdoes.tumblr.com/

Views: 288

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Here an example, from the film Dune.



They're probably sending you the TV pan and scan versions.  I don't understand it either.  Why would anyone want to watch a chopped up film?  But they do.  And some of them get mighty riled up about the "black bars".  Enough so that you can still find discs of the pan and scan versions for sale (especially at places whose names end in "mart".) 

Best you could do with Netflix is call CS and see if they can send you a disc with the proper aspect ratio.  They might even be able to help you find it on IW, you never know.

866-579-7115

Nothing new and we have discussed this here. Netflix has been doing this for years.

The problem I seem to have is subtitles getting cut off the bottom of the screen.  That's when Netflix even offers foreign films with subtitles.

Have you tried adjusting the height of your picture?  Or raising it's centering function?

RSS

Badge

Loading…

Latest Activity

macroman replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"GMO OMG (2013. Food Documentary)=Everybody has to eat and a growing number but still relatively few people are aware of how pervasive genetically modified foods (GMOs) are in the US and how challenging it is to know whether what we're eating is…"
36 minutes ago
Dig-Me-Up left a comment for David
"Well at this point I can't say that Extant will or can turn into a good series or not. The big part of the story is what secrets there are and how they will be revealed. I think a lot of ideas suffer when they are turned into long drawn out TV…"
4 hours ago
Nerves replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"Three Sisters (1970)Based on a theatre production that Laurence Olivier directed at the Royal National Theatre in 1967, the film is little more than a record of the stage production. Nearly three hours of bored, miserable people looking for a…"
6 hours ago
David left a comment for Dig-Me-Up
"Ok, thanks for the head's up.  I might give it a try, though I have to admit my expectations are pretty low. :P  Most average TV to me is pretty abysmal.  I thought The Strain was going to be good, but it's so far, pretty…"
7 hours ago
Ando replied to pterosaur's discussion 'The Listening Thread: Part NEIN!' in the group The Soundtracks to Our Lives
"Nice, slow, soulful take. Still partial to Mccan's, tho. :-) "
8 hours ago
David replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"Here's a podcast on films if interested.  Are there any you listen too?  http://podcastpickle.com/ They were covering surreal films as well."
10 hours ago
eviltimes replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"Ghost in the Shell ARISE Border 3 Ghost Tears     2014   NR   59 min   JP   EN subs   8/10 Part 3 of 4 in the prequel to the GITS:SAC series. As the Major and the rest of what will become Section…"
12 hours ago
eviltimes replied to pterosaur's discussion 'The Listening Thread: Part NEIN!' in the group The Soundtracks to Our Lives
"Tubes - Don't Want to Wait Anymore"
12 hours ago
Dig-Me-Up left a comment for David
"Extant is on tonight at 9 PM. Just a reminder. http://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/extant/tv-listings/580829 ; "
13 hours ago
eviltimes replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"Oh, yes.  Horse or not - giddy up!"
20 hours ago
Don Wilson is now a member of Netflix Movie Fans
21 hours ago
Ando replied to The Professor's discussion 'What did you watch today? v 34.0'
"Humoresque (1946) Wealthy socialite, Joan Crawford, falls for poor, young, violinist, John Garfield. Isaac Stern's beautiful playing, Oscar Levant's wonderful turn as Garfield's lifetime buddy and fellow artiste, classic 40s black…"
21 hours ago

© 2014   Created by droidmaker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service