Netflix Movie Fans

Welcome to version 33, the Egg McMuffin of discussions. 

 

The first post in this thread will be # 14,394. 

 

The ghost of George Sanders reminds you to link your films, and that one should feel free to move on if bored. 

Views: 18902

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

Catch-22 (1970)

5/5 Stars

Comedies aren't known for their cinematography but director of photography David Watkin's work on this film is worth the price of admission on its own. You also get an all star cast: Orson, Perkins, Newhart, ...Alan Arkin is especially memorable. The commentary by director Mike Nichols and Steven Soderbergh is both entertaining and enlightening.

Three great (although different) war movies in 1970:  Kelly's HeroesM*A*S*H* and the truly amazing Catch-22.  If you've ever read Joe Heller's book it's an amazing feat to turn it into a comprehensible film.

"You killed him! 

But he died a rich man.

But he's dead, what good is money?

Then his parents will get it.

But his parents are rich!

Then they'll understand."

I was thinking to quote those very lines from that exchange between Yossarian and Milo as they  encapsulate the essence of the novel and film: that no sacrifice is too great if it's in the interest of the American military/industrial complex. Buck Henry wrote the lines "They're rich. - Then they'll understand" and according to Nichols and Soderbergh, Heller said he wished he had thought of it himself.

One of those few instances where the movie is better than the book (imo).

Yep.  This one and Fight Club.  Rare instances where the screenplay/film far surpassed the original material.

Rare instances where the screenplay/film far surpassed the original material.


Jesus . . .

One of those few instances where the movie is better than the book (imo). 

 

Moses . . .

The book became tedious in its repetition. Scheisskopf jokes are only funny the first 17 times.

Can't blame Sev - he's only read it in the original Klingon.

Scheisskopf jokes are only funny the first 17 times

 

True . . . if all you can see are Scheisskopf jokes.

Of course that's not all there is, but it became a nuisance and detracted from my overall appreciation of the book. I liked the film better (though I haven't seen it in... 10-15 years).

What Sevorin is saying is that your opinion is wrong. Change it.

RSS

Badge

Loading…

Latest Activity

Dig-Me-Up replied to Dig-Me-Up's discussion 'Spoilers for horror movies' in the group The Spoiler Zone
"I have a mini spoiler alert picture that I will be using a lot more in the future..... Feel free to copy and use it. It's a convenient size,. not too too big.... "
16 minutes ago
Dig-Me-Up replied to Dig-Me-Up's discussion 'Spoilers for horror movies' in the group The Spoiler Zone
"I was thinking today that "The Titanic" must be the worst film for a remake. All of the elements are in place and there is no room for a surprise ending, Unless you make it a weird film. The people are rescued by aliens in a UFO.  I…"
18 minutes ago
eviltimes replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
"James Gandolfini sleeps with the fishes,  Heart attack in Italy. "
25 minutes ago
David replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
"How are you capturing these motion pics?  Whenever I try to save them they freeze in static form."
37 minutes ago
David replied to Dig-Me-Up's discussion 'Spoilers for horror movies' in the group The Spoiler Zone
"Well, I think what would help, if someone puts up the title to the film first, and then someone would  what film they are fixing to spoil, otherwise since I don't want a spoiler for a film I have not seen, I would avoid the thread like the…"
40 minutes ago
David replied to Dig-Me-Up's discussion 'Spoilers for horror movies' in the group The Spoiler Zone
"Well, it's understand about the boat sinking with Titanic that that would be a given, but then the love story ending as it did might spoil it for someone that hasn't seen the film as that was a part of the history/mythology that a general…"
44 minutes ago
JDoors replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
"F'n whoa!"
52 minutes ago
Snorii replied to spiderpig's discussion 'Pics or GTFO V4.0'
1 hour ago
eviltimes left a comment for Slappy
"Slappy, your pictures are all disappearing!  Is it one of those post directly from somewhere thingies instead of downloading them to your HDD and then copying them here?"
4 hours ago
eviltimes replied to Dig-Me-Up's discussion 'Spoilers for horror movies' in the group The Spoiler Zone
""Eli" in Let the Right One In is a boy."
4 hours ago
eviltimes replied to Dig-Me-Up's discussion 'Spoilers for horror movies' in the group The Spoiler Zone
4 hours ago
eviltimes replied to Dig-Me-Up's discussion 'Spoilers for horror movies' in the group The Spoiler Zone
"Ah, but Moon really is good on subsequent watches, especially if you're a long time SF fan and have seen films like Silent Running, the Russian Solaris, etc."
4 hours ago

© 2013   Created by droidmaker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service