Share 'Musicals- Can be so wrong or so right.'

West Side Story. The Music Man. Oklahoma. My Fair Lady. Guys and Dolls. (Okay, I haven't seen Guys and Dolls. But I've heard the songs.) I love Shirley Jones, but Carousel was so poorly realized. The accents were supposed to be Maine and they all ended up sounding like extras from Oklahoma. What are your favorite hits and or misses and why?